In the vacuum of information following the mysterious disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, mother of TODAY show co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, a tide of online speculation has begun to clash with the calculated pace of a multi-agency investigation.
As theories circulate through social media—some suggesting that Savannah’s brother-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, could be a prime suspect—law enforcement officials are fighting to maintain a balance between transparency and the integrity of a high-stakes search. While Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos has declined to definitively rule out anyone, including the family members who were the last to see the 84-year-old, he has simultaneously pushed back against “reckless” reporting.
Forensic Realities and Fears
During a sobering press briefing on February 5, Sheriff Nanos confirmed a grim forensic detail: DNA testing has verified that blood droplets discovered outside Nancy Guthrie’s Tucson home belong to her. While Nanos admitted he is “certainly fearful” regarding the fate of the octogenarian, he maintained a stance of cautious optimism.
“We are operating from a position that until we know, she’s out there [and] she’s alive,” Nanos told reporters.
Nancy Guthrie has been missing since the evening of Saturday, January 31. The timeline of her final known movements has become the primary focus for investigators:
-
Saturday Evening: Nancy was reportedly taken by an Uber driver to the home of her daughter, Annie. Police have since located and interviewed that driver.
-
9:45 p.m.: Following an evening of dinner and games, Nancy’s son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, drove her back to her own residence. This remains the last confirmed sighting.
-
1:47 a.m. Sunday: Nancy’s Ring doorbell camera was disconnected. Authorities have not confirmed if the device was destroyed or simply disabled.
Countering the “Reckless” Narrative
The investigation has been plagued by a series of unverified media reports, ranging from claims of forced entry to a smashed camera found at the scene. Nanos was quick to dismiss the origin of these rumors, stating, “Someone mentioned there was forced entry. I have no clue where that came from.”
The Sheriff also directly addressed speculation fueled by former NewsNation host Ashleigh Banfield, who suggested Cioni might be a suspect. Nanos characterized such assertions as dangerous. “It’s really kind of reckless to report that someone is a suspect when they could very well be a victim,” he noted.
However, Nanos stopped short of clearing anyone. When pressed on Cioni’s status, he was blunt about the scope of the inquiry: “We’re actively looking at everybody we come across in this case. We would be irresponsible if we didn’t talk to everybody. The Uber driver, the gardener, the pool person… everybody’s still a suspect in our eyes. Does that mean we have a prime suspect? No.”
The Mexico Factor: A Race Against Geography
The difficulty of the case is compounded by Tucson’s geography. Art Del Cueto, a veteran U.S. Customs and Border Protection officer who lives near the Guthrie residence, warned that the rugged terrain and proximity to the international border represent a significant hurdle.
“If somebody gets spooked, they can make it into Mexico in under an hour and a half,” Del Cueto told the Daily Mail. This proximity, he suggested, may be why authorities are being exceptionally guarded with the details of their progress.
The Rise of the “Imposter”
The investigation has already been forced to divert resources to handle opportunistic fraud. Federal authorities recently announced the arrest of Derrick Callella in Hawthorne, California. Callella is accused of sending fake ransom demands for Bitcoin to the Guthrie family.
FBI Phoenix Special Agent Heith Janke labeled Callella a “total imposter,” issued a stern warning to others looking to profit from the tragedy: “We will investigate and ensure you are held accountable for your actions.”
Ongoing Efforts
The FBI continues to offer a $50,000 reward for information leading to Nancy Guthrie’s safe return or the apprehension of those involved in her disappearance. As the investigation enters its second week, the combination of forensic challenges and a nearby international border suggests that finding the truth behind Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance may be one of the region’s most difficult cases in recent memory.
